A lot of people have started trying to use the recent and tragic rampage at Virginia Tech to further their own political agenda. Gun control, gun ownership, immigration, isolation, mental health advocates, tough-love advocates, everyone is just itching to do whatever they can to use this event to further their own cause.
As for myself, I just read Battle Royale by Koushun Takami. It was just last weekend that I decided to pick it up, and discovered that the Borders next door to the coffee shop I was at actually had a copy in stock even though their computer didn't even think they could order it.
Spoiler warning: Yeah, spoilers follow. If you're interested and don't want any plot details spoiled — and if you are interested, you should really go in as "cold" as you can — stop reading here.
Battle Royale is set in an alternate-history fascist Japan right around our own time that, as part of its enforcement of social order, every year or two runs The Program. In The Program, a third-year junior high class is — without their knowledge or consent — taken to a battleground, armed, and forced to fight each other to the death. That's 9th grade to Americans, 14-to-15-year-olds. They're forced to fight by means of electronic remote monitoring & explosive collars around their necks; if nobody dies over a 24-hour period, everyone dies. If there's more than one person left alive at the end of The Program, everyone dies.
It is, in short, some fucked up shit.
I won't spoil the ending, but I will point out that it was extremely controversial in Japan as a novel, and then as a film, and there are persistent stories that an American remake — rather than an American release — of the film are in the works.
So, how does this tie in to the Virginia Tech tragedy? I'm a pro-gun liberal; I think people have the right to a wide variety of weapons, and the right to carry them, and that those rights should be protected. However, I also happen to think that weapons do need some amount of control. Having lots of students carrying or having access to weapons at Virginia Tech wouldn't have helped any more than having very few armed; the situation was too extreme for people to deal with rationally. And the Battle Royale film's infamous lighthouse scene provides a very good illustration of this.
The problem is that while an armed society is a polite society, that's only true so long as everyone is polite. As soon as someone starts being rude it can quickly become a paranoid society. Is it better for everyone to be helpless in the face of extreme violence? No, but it's not entirely bad, either, that not everybody is ready to play Rambo at a moment's notice.
I just hope that this event doesn't remove what little rationality is left from the discussion of such issues. In either direction.